7 Books That Are Not About What You Think They’re About

I heard an author & book reviewer (Ryan Holiday) comment that at lot of books are about one thing…but are actually about another thing. And “the another thing” usually a something related to the author’s personal life.

The example he gave was that The Road by Cormac McCarthy is actually about parenting. I’ve never heard a comment ring so ridiculous but so true at the same time.

The Road is one of the greatest American books I’ve ever read. It’s one of those books that just stuck with me – even though I didn’t know why. But I read The Road just before becoming a parent. And yeah, the whole meta-metaphor of the book is just about how exactly one generation passes human values to the next, in spite of it all.

After a long rabbit hole, I ended up handing Claude my Books Read spreadsheet to give me a few more examples. Here are six others that I’ve read that all have a meta-metaphor.

Walden by Thoreau

Walden is manifestly a book about living deliberately on eleven dollars. Latently it is a book about a dead brother. John Thoreau cut himself shaving in 1842 and died of tetanus in Henry’s arms; Henry developed the symptoms himself, psychosomatically, and nearly went with him. He went to the pond three years later, and the main writing project he took there was A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers – an account of a boat trip he and John had taken, which is really an elegy with a river laid over it. You own both books. Read together, Walden stops being a manual for simplicity and becomes what a man does instead of mourning.

The First Man by Camus

The First Man is presented as an unfinished autobiographical novel about a boy in Algiers, recovered from the wreck of the car he died in. Its dedication is “To you who will never be able to read this book” – his mother, illiterate and nearly deaf, who could not read a sentence he ever wrote. Once you see that, the whole Camus shelf reorganizes itself. The absurd is not a seminar position; it’s a description of his mother’s life – labor without narrative, endurance without explanation – and Sisyphus is the argument that such a life is not a waste. He spent a career building a philosophy that would justify a woman who couldn’t follow it.

The Summer Book by Tove Jansson

The Summer Book reads as a charming novel about a grandmother and a small girl on a Finnish island. The child’s mother is dead. It’s stated once, plainly, early, and then never raised again – and everything else in the book is the shape of that hole: the grandmother’s irritability, the girl’s rages, the father who is always in the frame and never speaking. Jansson wrote it the summer after her own mother died. It is the cleanest example I know of a book whose subject is present only as an absence.

The Sherlock Holmes stories by Conan Doyle

In the Holmes Stories, the manifest content is puzzles. The latent content is a city that had become unreadable – London roughly doubling, full of strangers whose origins you could no longer infer – and Holmes is the consoling fantasy that surfaces still tell the truth, that a trouser knee confesses. Note also where the trouble keeps coming from: Utah, Agra, the Andamans, the Indian Mutiny, the Australian goldfields. The crimes are almost always the empire coming home. And notice that Holmes is doing to people exactly what your three Tristan Gooley books do to landscape – the same faith that a seemingly unintelligible, unpredictable world is legible if you’re disciplined enough to look.

The Buried Giant by Ishiguro

The Buried Giant is costumed as Arthurian fantasy: a mist that erases memory, ogres, an aging knight. It is about a long marriage, and about the fact that a couple’s peace may rest on things they’ve agreed not to remember. The ending is a boatman who ferries couples to an island and separates all but the truly bonded – which is to say the book is about which of two old people dies first, and whether honesty at the end is a gift or a demolition. Ishiguro’s second subject, running underneath, is national: Rwanda, Yugoslavia, postwar France, postwar Japan. When is forgetting the price of peace, and when is it cowardice.

Meditations by Marcus Aurelius

The self-help industry around it – sells Meditations as a manual. It isn’t. It’s a private notebook with no reader intended, written on campaign, and its actual content is repetition: he tells himself the same handful of things over and over. Don’t be angry at people. Remember you’ll die. Stop caring what they think. You do not repeat an instruction you’ve mastered. What the book records is not wisdom achieved but a man losing the same argument with himself for a decade, in a tent, at the edge of the Danube. That’s a far better book than the one being sold.

Those are just the seven that an LLM identified from the books that I’ve actually read. This topic never really came up in my Intro to Literature classes in college, but I love the line of criticism.

Get Posts Automagically

…also via RSS or Fediverse – just copy link & paste in your favorite reader :)

Similar Posts